Last Updated on April 21, 2025 by Katrina

Photo credit: Belhurst Castle and Winery

The 11 narrow lakes in upstate New York provide stunning scenery. Add wineries and quaint small towns and the Finger Lakes area make for an unbeatable getaway. While you’re here, check out the dozens of waterfalls, and explore the historic town of Seneca Falls, the birthplace of the American women’s rights movement. The lodging options in the Finger Lakes area tend toward smaller, independent hotels, brimming with charm. Here are the best hotels in the Finger Lakes.

Watkins Glen Harbor Hotel (16 N Franklin St.; 607-535-6116) Watkins Glen

Forbes writes that this 107-room hotel, “nestled on the shores of Seneca Lake, is the perfect vantage point from which to explore this vibrant destination.” The hotel offers two dining options, an indoor pool, and easy access to the 19 waterfalls at Watkins Glen State Park. “Awesome location, walking distance to Watkins Glen State Park, restaurants, shops,” writes a Google reviewer. “The rooms are clean and spacious, and staff is always helpful. Every morning on every floor they set up a coffee bar with everything you need along with tea and hot chocolate.” >> Book this hotel for less

Belhurst Castle and Winery (4069 W Lake Rd.; 315-781-0201) Geneva

“Check into a circa 1885 castle for the ultimate romantic stay on Seneca Lake,” writes Afar about this 47-room hotel listed on the National Register of Historic Properties. The resort is spread across three distinct buildings: a stone castle and two mansions, one of which is a Georgian Revivalist. Along with its own winery and a full-service spa, the resort has a lake, gardens, and two dining options. “Beautiful location right on the lake,” writes a Google reviewer. “The main castle is an old building so there are some creaky stairs etc. to be expected. There is a spigot that you can get free wine out of. Breakfast is included but it is just cold cereal, fruit, bagels etc.” >> Book this hotel for less

Inns of Aurora Resort & Spa (391 Main St.; 315-364-8888) Aurora

The five inns that make up this small resort boast amenities including a spa, loaner bikes, art kits and stargazing tours. “Founded in 1789, the quaint village of Aurora looks like something out of a fairytale,” writes Forbes Travel Guide, “and the Inns of Aurora fit right in, especially The Aurora Inn … a stately brick Federal-style manor overlooks Cayuga Lake.” A Tripadvisor user writes that “renovations made each mansion unique, comfortable. Enjoyed the fireplace and large en suite bathrooms with heated floor. Had a fantastic spa experience with pools, eucalyptus steam room and a reinvigorating cold plunge.” >> Book this hotel for less

The Lake House on Canandaigua (770 S Main St.; 800-228-2801) Canandaigua

Travel+Leisure calls this 125-room hotel “ultra-chic” with “understated, contemporary luxury and a comprehensive wellness program at its Willowbrook Spa.” A Google reviewer writes that it is a “definite five stars. This hotel is the epitome of simple beauty and relaxation. The different bars and lounges are very relaxing, have comfortable chairs and sofas, and some games set on the tables. Outside, there is a pretty hot tub overlooking the lake, and a large accessible pool.” >> Book this hotel for less

The Statler Hotel at Cornell University (130 Statler Dr.; 607-254-2500) Ithaca

This 153-room luxury hotel is actually part of Cornell’s prestigious School of Hotel Administration, and staffed almost entirely by students. U.S. News & World Report calls it both a “serene and homey place … just because it’s run by the university doesn’t mean you should expect lackluster service.” While there’s no gym or pool, you’re close to Taughannock Falls State Park and Cayuga Lake. A Google reviewer writes that “I have stayed at this hotel a number of times: The rooms are elegant and comfortable. There is a great full-service restaurant and the location is amazing, right on campus. And the service is incredible.” >> Book this hotel for less